So this is something that came up this week while reading a really awesome novel: I was really enjoying everything...until the university professor comes on the scene. Because, lets be honest, as a Professor, there are very few times that this character is portrayed correctly. Actually...I can't think of a single time that I've seen it done well or accurately.
Caveat: every department, university, and career is very different. I am biased toward what it's like to be an anthropology professor in a smaller school, but with a focus on research. Things are super different at the big R1 schools (research first), and vastly different from smaller teaching colleges. Still...it's *always* going to be a busy and stressful job.
So, what got the burr in my butt about this? The guy shows up to work and got to spend the whole day, door shut, just doing research. He didn't have to attend faculty meetings, or read his emails (well, memos in the book, but really NO one uses memos any more). Actually, he avoided interaction with the rest of his department pretty much on the whole all of the time. AND, the kicker, he got to PICK where he worked. JUST NO. On all counts.
Haha, okay, so yeah I know, sometimes it's necessary to bend the rules a little to make a story work. I guess it just irked me because it got me thinking that never, anywhere, have I seen this type of character done well. To add to this, the Professor character is EVERYWHERE. Think about it: they are on almost every show, and many movies, let alone books galore. (and not just characters that are called "professor" and aren't one, too.)
Anyhow, things to think about if you're going to write a professor character: we never have free time. I work pretty much 24/7. I always have to have my email around, because it gets insane in the blink of an eye. I work with people around the world on research, let alone my students in classes and the lab. If I'm in my office, I'm almost never left alone, with the rare exception of right around a big holiday. Students, other professors, random people off the street (and oh gods could I tell you stories about this), let alone research collaborators, etc., are ALWAY stopping by. Getting a chance to work on a single project and dedicate some serious hours to it flat out always means I have to work from home. Which I do. A lot.
I'm never going to be able to take an unexpected trip to see some strange event. Not in the middle of the semester, especially. Professors don't get substitute teachers. We may be lucky enough to have a grad student or TA who can cover a few days for us, both long absences are next to impossible. I'll be missing two days later this semester for a work conference and it's insane attempting to get that all worked out. Sure, I can cancel class...but that can count against me on my evaluations and that's not something I can afford to mess with (they count toward raises, tenure, annual evals, which if you think about it is really screwed up).
Okay, last one: the academic job market is a pretty screwy place. This is a huge post in and of itself, but let's suffice it to say that new, permanent positions only open up when someone retires or dies. Sometimes a university opens a new position when the money allows for it, but it doesn't happen often. So, once you're done with grad school and basically desperate for a job, you kind of have to apply to the random positions that are open. And that could be ANYWHERE. (And no university hires its own graduates.) This is how I ended up in the middle of Montana. Sure, maybe later I'll be able to apply for a position that'll come open elsewhere, but getting a tenure track position to begin with is like winning the lotto--getting one where you want to live (wherever that might be) is next to impossible. So, a character that just applies to any old department because they want to live in XYZ city--nope. Not gonna happen.
Anyhow, this is a random rant of a post about professor life. If you want to be true to life to on in your writing, it would be best to be really familiar with academic life. Or just make your character in some other profession that you know more about :)
/rant :)
I feel the same way when I see novelists portrayed in books. Very few authors have our agents bugging us for our next book. They couldn't care less, right? If you write another one, they'll sell it and if not, they might give us an email nudge in a year or two, but they're not going to show up at our house. I guess if you're a multi-millionaire like Stephen King who sells a billion copies of every book, it's different, and those are the ones who write the books that teach other authors what it's "like" to be an author. Really, it's pretty boring. And yes, having worked in an office for 19 years, I can attest to the fact that NOBODY uses memos anymore. That's just weird! The last time I saw one of those was the 90s...
ReplyDeleteSeriously, I loved this post! Your voice is strong and true....methinks you need to have a prof character in an upcoming book! Maybe another YA or even dipping a toe into MG? Mahalo for making me smile today -- and wince in agony with you!
ReplyDeleteNeedless to say, Dan Brown hasn't spent much time in the real academia.
ReplyDeleteBut if you are an archaeology professor, you do get time off to search for lost arks, right?
ReplyDeleteYeah, like Jenny, I totally imagined you like Indiana Jones! ;) A lot of my professors always looked rundown, and I went to a small university too.
ReplyDeleteI love that graphic at the beginning of the post! Thanks for such great insight on not only the professor character but the professor life.
ReplyDeleteLOL. I actually do have some insight into this field, since we looked at pursuing it once upon a time and rubbed shoulders with several professor friends. We decided it was better to go into the business field.
ReplyDeleteBut let me also echo what Stephanie said. My goodness, Castle--the TV series--drove me crazy. When was that guy supposed to have actually done any writing? Or social media schmoozing? Or actual live events? Fiction, eh?
I can totally see how this would irk you! As an adjunct professor I know that there are no subs and can imagine how busy it would be to be a full time professor. I have had to attend department meetings.
ReplyDeleteI get the same feeling when I read about schools/teachers in books and I can tell the author has never been a teacher. It can be hard to get past things that are totally unrealistic and wouldn't actually happen in a school setting.